Three tricks for better vocal overdubs
Saturday, December 20th, 2008
“In a lot of ways, everything is sort of judged by the voice.” -Kevin Barnes from Of Montreal








“In a lot of ways, everything is sort of judged by the voice.” -Kevin Barnes from Of Montreal








The Brigadier’s albums sound as if they were meticulously assembled in a 1979-era world-class million dollar studio. Electric Light Orchestra, 10cc, and Queen are all sonic reference points, as well as more recent artists like Teenage Fanclub.
Are you serious? From the sound of your vocals, I thought you had a midrange microphone and a high-end preamp! What microphone model are you using? And which 4-track?
On “The Rise and Fall of Responsibility,” many of the songs seem to revolve around the transition from being a teenager to a young adult. Were there any real-life situations that inspired the songs?
Postal Blue is proof that, in the age of the internet, it’s optional whether you sound like your home base’s music scene. Aside from the sole Portuguese track on their latest EP, Road to Happiness, if you close your eyes when listening to Postal Blue, you’ll swear that their chimey guitar pop is from some sleepy overcast town in the UK, not from the tropics of Brazil. Fans of The Smiths and Echo and The Bunnymen would be wise to check them out. Heck, it’s only a mouse click away! You can go right to Postal Blue’s Last.fm page and listen to almost everything they’ve officially released.
It’s a more straightforward record with proper pop songs, as opposed to our album where we did a lot of experimenting with moods and song structures. Production-wise, it’s just us playing the songs as we do during band practice too, with barely any overdubs and not much in the way of synths and samples. The only exception is the last song (I’m Glad You Know), which called for a different approach.
Some lyrics are very heartfelt, like in The World Doesn’t Need You, Asleep, and Weather Sensitive, while others, which I won’t name, are just vague lines that sound complimentary to the instrumentation. I get a little Liz Fraser-y sometimes.“So how do you record drums?”
That’s one question that inevitably arises when talking with a fellow home studio DIYer.
The question isn’t pointed at microphone selection and placement, but at something much more fundamental: How do you tell the computer to start and stop recording?
There’s a lot of hassles involved in recording real drums. And if you’re recording yourself, chances are you’ve got an additional headache: It’s not easy to press a key on the computer to start recording, run to the drum set, gain composure, and play a winning drum take.
In recent years, products like the $200 Tranzport have entered the market, which diminish the need for basement relay races.
I needed the Tranzport a few years before it existed, so I came up with a $40 homebrew solution using a wireless joypad and free software. It doesn’t have all the features of the Tranzport, but it might be good enough for your needs. It’s been good enough for mine — I’ve recorded almost all of The Simple Carnival’s tracks this way. I haven’t been (pardon the pun) remotely tempted to upgrade to something better.

The Logitech Cordless RumblePad 2 is a standard wireless gamepad, and, as you can see from the picture above, I’ve put stickers on its buttons to represent the Pro Tools LE functions I use most often when tracking. Here’s a more detailed view.

The right joystick doesn’t do anything — maybe I’ll come up with a use for it one day. The gamepad handles rewind and fast forward. The up and down directions are not used.
Here’s a diagram showing the buttons on the back of the gamepad.

JoyToKey, a free Windows application, maps — you guessed it — joystick functions to keyboard buttons. Here’s what my JoyToKey setup looks like.

And this is how I record drums! And flute, marimba, vocals, organ, piano, congas, guitar, bass, Fender Rhodes, Clavinet, synthesizers — anything where I’m not standing directly in front of the computer keyboard.
Yes, sometimes I have to squint if I’m moving the mouse pointer with the joystick on the other side of the room. It’s just something you get used to after a while. On the other hand, most of these functions don’t require you to look at the screen anyway. After you arm your tracks, just about everything else can be done with your eyes closed.
There’s a nice bonus when using this technique with a guitar, or any instrument with pickups: Since you’re not performing in front of your computer monitor, you won’t pick up any interference from it.
Have fun on the other side of the room.
You want grunge? You want compression? You want a grimy, filthy-sounding microphone where everything that comes out the other end sounds lo-fi in a (sometimes) pleasing way?
Well, if you don’t already have this magic box, look no further than your local OfficeMax.

That’s right, a standard microcassette recorder is your gateway to a world of sonic suckiness.
Note that this is not one of those newfangled digital recorders — although I’m sure there could be uses for that, too. I’m talking about the ones which use those tiny little cassette tapes that are getting harder and harder to find every year as technology marches on.
A microcassette recorder isn’t just for college lectures or surreptitiously collecting inadmissible evidence. No sirree. It should be a required piece of gear in any home studio.
Obviously, you can use these recorders as rough idea collectors. What’s not so obvious is that they often fit perfectly into a plain old mic clip.
If you sing and play an instrument when writing songs, a microcassette recorder makes a great “vocal” mic. The built-in compression on these devices is usually so crazy that it will capably pick up the sound of your instrument, even if the mic is pointed at your mouth.
(By the way, if you put the microcassette recorder in a mic clip, be sure the mic clip isn’t pressing against the tape door area. You can get some sounds which are even more screwed up that way — you’re messing with the tape head azimuth alignment — but you could also hurt your recorder. You’ve been warned!)
If you’re serious about using a microcassette recorder as an idea catcher, do yourself a favor and invest in a bunch of microcassettes. Then, throw them in a Trivial Pursuit card box or something similar. Keep all the tapes rewound to the beginning, and pull out a random one when inspiration strikes.
But let’s get to the heart of what these gadgets excel at doing: acting as a lo-fi mic/compressor combo.
Start recording with the microcassette recorder, then run a cable out of the earphone jack to your DAW’s line input. If your microcassette recorder is like most, then voila! You’ve got a unique-sounding mic for when you’re in a grungy mood.
Try the recorder as an overhead or room mic for drums. Try it on piano and check out the squashed, Beatles-like tones. Use it on vocals for a telephone effect. Play back only the vocal tracks or some other element through your monitors, position the microcassette recorder appropriately, then record the microcassette recorder’s output as a new track. (Be careful not to send the newly recorded signal back to your monitors, or you’ll get feedback… although that might be interesting, too!)
Note that the mechanical parts of the tapes themselves can contribute an undesirable noise to this “mic”, so you might want to remove the tape and stick your finger over the safety tab mechanism when pressing the record button.
Another thing to watch out for is that, depending on the model, the microcassette recorder’s circutry might delay the incoming signal by, say, 1/10 of a second. If this is the case, your recorded microcassette mic performance might feel a bit out of the pocket compared to the tracks you’ve already recorded. So you may need to adjust your microcassette mic tracks after recording them in your DAW.
It’s also possible to use a microcassette recorder in a time-shifted sort of way. If the tape noise doesn’t bother you (and why should it? The sound is already awful), throw in a microcassette and record an entire vocal take onto it. Try it with both record speeds. The slower speed adds an extra layer of grunge by severely attenuating the high end. Which speed is best depends on the source material and how nasty you want the sound to be.
After you’ve recorded your part, play it back and record the result into your DAW. You will need to shift things around, as it’s unlikely the recordings will be synchronized (or stay synchronized). You may find this “out of time” effect appealing, depending on the song.
I used this time-shifted mic technique (with a backwards reverb) for the “radio” voices on Really Really Weird. You can hear the microcassette recorder voice the second time “Really Really Weird” is sung on this clip. I also used a lot of microcassette mic stuff (piano, drum room mic, vocals) on Hey Lancaster, a song from the upcoming Girls Aliens Food album. (Sorry, no sound clip yet!)
And if nothing else, you can use a microcassette recorder to make beatbox patterns. Tapping on the recorder could make interesting source material for a dirty-sounding loop, or something that pops up momentarily.
Did I miss any other uses?
Welcome to the Songs and Sonics blog. I’m your host, Jeff Boller, main songwriter and performer in The Simple Carnival.
You’re probably wondering, “Who? The Simple what?” That’s OK, because I don’t know who you are either. And I don’t know how you found this site, but please make yourself at home.
So what’s this all about? Well, within these electronic pages you’ll find a smorgasbord of tales from the front lines of songwriting, music production, and working with bizarre objects that make grinding, belching, unwelcome noises (which can be, but are not limited to, actual musical instruments). We’ll take a close look at the creative process of making music. We’ll have some audio show-and-tell. There will be interviews with other artists who are doing cool things with sound. Mostly though, I hope that this blog will provide you with ideas and inspiration for your own creative endeavors.
“OK,” you say. “But who the heck are you, and why should I care?”
Fair question. I’m a 30-something singer/songwriter/multi-instrumentalist based near Pittsburgh, PA. Since 2001, I’ve fronted The Simple Carnival, a pop recording project that sounds like what might happen if Harry Nilsson and The Beach Boys collaborated on Sesame Street. To date, The Simple Carnival has released three EPs and the first real, honest-to-goodness album (titled Girls Aliens Food) scheduled for release in late 2008 on Sundrift Records. I play all the instruments and sing all the parts on these recordings.
My music career has led me from writing and producing songs for other artists, to recording bands at professional studios, to directing video productions, and ultimately… to finding a 9-5, non-audio job that actually pays the bills.
So if you’re looking for advice on how write that hit song or make it big in the music industry, you’ve come to the wrong place. I don’t mind communicating with a large audience, but my background is mostly in writing and recording songs for a specific niche, and it’s not the same audience that closely follows the Top 40. Write what you know and all that. Still, even if you’re not into the kind of music I do, I hope to keep things general enough so that the majority of the content here is relevant to anyone doing creative things with sound.
You can probably expect a new post every few days, with a big article about once a week — as long as there’s something to talk about. I look forward to your feedback, as it will help steer the conversation toward the things you find most interesting. And yes, I do consider this blog a conversation. So please post some comments to help get things rolling!